Roxbury Farm

June 13, 2010

Ever since starting The Veg Table, I have been non-stop thinking, dreaming and talking about food, not to mention eating it.  The more I’ve thought about it, the more committed to changing our food system I have become.  Already, many hopeful and exciting ideas  have surfaced;  it seems the food movement is gaining steam.   However, and as Ben Hewitt (blog post book review) suggests, we must be critical thinkers and really work to understand how our food system can be transformed. One concept that is gaining popularity across the country is Community Supported Agriculture.

Community Supported Agriculture is a direct marketing relationship between small-scale sustainable farmers and consumers, known as shareholders.  Shareholders put down a lump sum of money before the season starts and receive a weekly box of vegetables throughout the harvest months.

CSA has emerged as one of the prominent models of local food distribution, but it can’t work for the nation if it isn’t economically sustainable. This summer I will be doing a comparative ethnographic study of three CSA farms: How do these farms manage economics with their shareholders?  Who, really, supports Community Supported Agriculture and how do those people conceive of their support?

I took my first research trip to Roxbury Farm in Kinderhook, NY at the beginning of the month. Mostly, I did what is called participant-observation research.  This means I worked on the farm, participated in what the farmers were doing, jotted ideas (very dirty notebook) and typed up field notes of detailed observations.  I had the chance to speak with all of the workers, a shareholder who is very involved with the economics of the farm, and the farm owners.  These people are truly committed to sustainable agriculture and just economics.  Roxbury Farm has 1,100 shareholders (one of the biggest CSA farms in the nation) and is the only CSA of the three in my study  that is economically self-sufficient. I had a lot of questions going into the week and came out with 23 pages of typed field notes!  I’ll just share a couple interesting high points with you now and will be sure to post more cohesive thoughts later.

One of the best parts of the week was getting to know Jean-Paul Courtens, the founder of Roxbury Farm, and his economic principles. He has a very different outlook on economic decisions than most business owners do. He argues that not all investments need to have money returns.

An investment can improve the working environment,  make a dreaded job easier, or increase safety for employees–great returns that might be ignored by someone trying only to maximize profit. Jean-Paul invested in special tractor attachments that improve operator safety and a high-tech bin washer, expensive items that he says are worth it. Jean-Paul has let down his self-interest in order to improve the work of his employees. This idea is also extended to his shareholders.  Instead of making as much money as he can, he engages in a conversation with his shareholders about the price of a share. This is not a market idea. However, it seems to be working; the CSA has been active for over two decades.  After all, it is not surprising that employees who are treated well work hard.  Nor is it hard to believe that a person who feels a part of the farm’s decisions will sign on for another season.

The share holder I met is actually writing a book about CSA and conducted a member survey for Roxbury Farm.  We spoke about an alternative model of supply and demand that he proposed for CSA. His main argument is that the demand for CSA changes depending on how long you are a shareholder.  The more seasons go by the more you get to learn about the farm, visit it, work on it and connect with it. This growing appreciation of the CSA makes you proud to be a member.  The more you want to be a member, the higher the demand for CSA and the less you come to care about the price of the share. Shirey elaborated that the great thing about CSA is that you can sign on only for the reason that it is a good deal, thinking of it simply as an economic transaction. This is good for you and for the farmer.  But unlike other economic transactions, you have the opportunity to get more involved, develop a loyalty, and be truly invested in the model.  Once people come to see CSA as an alternative to the destructive industrial food economy, they feel part of something good (and they are!) and continue buying a share.

It seems that people involved with CSA at Roxbury Farm are thinking about economics in a much different way than folks in the industrial system. There are certainly some challenges to this new type of economics but it is promising that Roxbury is thinking about worker safety and happiness, the satisfaction and support of their customers, and the health of the land.


5 Responses to “Roxbury Farm”

  1. I really hope you will blog about your comparative study. I think it’s fascinating and we need to show good data to Senators who are working against the concept.

  2. lemonpippin said

    It’s such a shame that people in this country are so adverse to socialist-resembling models when they actually work quite well in a lot of cases and have more respect for things that really matter: people, environment, community. It’ll be interesting to see this comparative study so that we can continue this conversation of how we can really implement changes to our food system.

    • Aubergine said

      It is also important to point out that a socialist-resembling model like CSA can be profitable. There just must be other concerns that take priority over maximizing profits. Thanks for you input, it will be really helpful as this project progresses.

  3. Alex said

    Hey Sig, great post.

    A couple things: one is that I love the alternate look at investments and returns. I met the guy who started Stone Creek Coffee out of Madison, WI and he looked at sustainability in a different way. He said it’s not just about recycling, reducing waste, etc. it’s about creating sustainable jobs by making sure his workers are happy, about creating a sustainable company that lasts a very long time.

    Also, I just visited a Kibbutz. Although I didn’t get to see a farm-Kibbutz (turns out the modern Kibbutzim in Israel no longer farm the land in most instances), I did listen to my tour guide, a member of the Kibbutz, speak about how it works–everyone works hard, everyone puts their money into the same pot, everyone supports everyone. It seems to work for them. Although I’m not sure I could live on a Kibbutz, I think there is much that can be taken from this socialist model and applied to our farming system and farms like the one you wrote about. I think most importantly, a holistic approach to farming. Kibbutzim and farms like Roxbury Farm definitely have that in common.

    I think looking at older Kibbutzim and how they have changed in Israel would be really interesting for you to research. Maybe you can see what did and did not work and pick out certain things that changed in Kibbutzim over the years and why those changes happened.

    • Aubergine said

      Thanks Alex, I will definitely look into Kibbutzim. One of the cool things about Roxbury is that it is employing socialist ideas and getting capitalist returns. While the Kibbutz may be a great, collective way to live, I think it is important to focus on how we can create alternative systems of food distribution that are economically profitable as well as sustainable. I would love to hear more about Stone Creek Coffee because I feel that Jean-Paul has a similar vision of employee support. Thanks for keeping up with The Veg Table when you are across the world!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: